Sarasota County crime victims can hold a property owner responsible when the owner knew about a risk of violence and didn’t provide reasonable security against it. That claim exists whether or not the attacker is caught, and it’s aimed at the party that carries insurance.
Three courthouses, one circuit
Sarasota County is in the Twelfth Judicial Circuit. The Silvertooth Judicial Center in downtown Sarasota is the main courthouse, and the circuit also sits at the South County Courthouse in Venice and the Sarasota County Justice Center. Civil claims are generally due within two years under section 95.11, and the clerk keeps a main office at the Historic Courthouse, 2000 Main St., in Sarasota.
Help for victims while the criminal case runs
If the Sarasota County Sheriff’s Office handled the call, it offers victim assistance and victim notification, and it publishes crime statistics. Your report and the calls to that address before your attack are where foreseeability gets proven, along with the owner’s incident reports. If you were treated at Sarasota Memorial Hospital, a Level II trauma center, I request the full chart.
The owner’s side of the evidence
Owners control the video, the guard schedules and the repair records, and cameras can overwrite within days. I send preservation letters early. If the property is an apartment or condo building with five or more units, the owner may claim the presumption in section 768.0706, and the owner has to prove it earned it. A jury can also weigh the attacker’s fault under section 768.0701. My years in criminal court taught me how violence at an address gets documented.
The firm serves all of Sarasota County, with dedicated city pages for Sarasota, North Port, and Venice.
The book
Hurt on Someone Else’s Property
The evidence race, the notice fight, the owner’s records, and why many of these cases end up filed as lawsuits, in one plain-English book on the days and weeks after a fall. Free to Tampa Bay residents, with the digital edition to read the moment you ask.
Common Questions
The person who attacked me was never caught. Do I still have a case?
Possibly. The claim is against the property owner, not the attacker, and it turns on whether the owner should have foreseen the crime and failed to provide reasonable security. An unidentified attacker does not defeat it.
What makes a negligent security case strong?
A documented history of prior crime at or near the property, paired with security that was missing, broken, or plainly inadequate to the known risk. That pattern is proven from the owner’s own records and the public police data.
What is the deadline?
Generally two years for the negligence claim, and the evidence race is far shorter, because surveillance video records over itself in days. Early legal help preserves what the case needs.
Related reading: negligent security, foreseeability and prior crime, and about Rory Safir.




