In Brief
No one has been charged in the January 24, 2026, shooting of Alex Pretti by federal immigration agents in Minneapolis, and the Hennepin County Attorney’s review was still open in late October. A state can charge a federal agent, but the agent can claim Supremacy Clause immunity under In re Neagle and move the case to federal court under 28 U.S.C. section 1442. Whether that immunity holds turns on facts, and the facts sit in evidence the federal government controls.
On This Page
- Where the Investigation Stands
- Yes, a State Can Charge a Federal Agent. Then Comes Neagle.
- What “Necessary and Proper” Means in a Shooting
- Why the Case Would Likely End Up in Federal Court Anyway
- Who Holds the Evidence
- Why Other States Are Watching
- Common Questions
- If Federal Officers Are Part of Your Case
- Further Reading
A few days after Alex Pretti was shot and killed by federal immigration agents in Minneapolis on January 24, 2026, I talked with Valley News Live in Fargo about the fight that broke out over the investigation. Minnesota’s Bureau of Criminal Apprehension, which normally investigates police shootings in the state, said federal agents took over the scene and told its investigators to leave. My first reaction was about the scene itself. I said “there’s no blanket rule that says federal agencies can take” exclusive control “of a crime scene just because their agents were involved.”
That segment was about evidence. Ten months later the bigger question sits behind it: can a county prosecutor in Minnesota charge a federal agent at all, and if she does, who gets to decide whether the case goes forward? The answer runs through an 1890 Supreme Court case about a deputy marshal guarding a Supreme Court justice, a federal statute that lets federal officers move a state prosecution into federal court, and a set of Justice Department rules about who can hand over federal files.
Where the Investigation Stands
No one has been charged in Pretti’s death. ABC News reported on October 27, 2026, that the Justice Department hadn’t brought charges and said its investigation was ongoing, and that the Hennepin County Attorney’s Office was still reviewing the case. County Attorney Mary Moriarty said in a statement that “the federal government continues to obstruct our investigation into Alex Pretti’s killing.” His father, Michael Pretti, said, “At every turn they have ignored us, misled us and shielded Alex’s killers.” A Justice Department spokesperson told ABC, “The timing is consistent with how these types of investigations proceed.”
In August, FOX 9 reported that Moriarty was reviewing the evidence and wouldn’t give a timeline. “I am optimistic that we will get to a charging decision, but I’m not going to say when that might be,” she said. Minnesota Attorney General Keith Ellison has worked the evidence fight alongside her from the start.
The clock on her office matters too. Moriarty didn’t run again, and MPR News reported on November 4 that state Rep. Cedrick Frazier narrowly won the race to replace her. The Intercept reported in September that Moriarty could leave the charging decision to her successor. As of this writing, I haven’t found a report of a decision either way.
Yes, a State Can Charge a Federal Agent. Then Comes Neagle.
Federal agents don’t have blanket immunity from state criminal law. A federal officer who commits a crime in Minnesota can be charged under Minnesota law, the same as anyone else. What the officer gets is a defense that ordinary defendants don’t have, and it comes from the Supremacy Clause of the Constitution.
The case that started it is In re Neagle, decided in 1890. David Neagle was a deputy U.S. marshal assigned to protect Justice Stephen Field while the justice rode circuit in California. When a man named David Terry attacked Field in a railroad dining room in Lathrop, California, Neagle shot and killed him. California charged Neagle with murder, and a federal court released him on habeas corpus. The Supreme Court agreed with the release. It held that if Neagle was held “to answer for an act which he was authorized to do by the law of the United States,” and “if in doing that act he did no more than what was necessary and proper for him to do, he cannot be guilty of a crime under the law of the State of California.”
That sentence is still the test, and it has two parts. The first asks whether the officer was doing a federal job. The second asks whether what the officer did was necessary and proper to that job. In a shooting, the second part is where the case is fought. The reason for the doctrine is practical, and courts state it plainly: federal agents “cannot be unduly constrained by fear of state prosecutions” if they’re going to do their jobs, as the Ninth Circuit put it in the case below. The limit is just as plain. The protection reaches only conduct that was necessary and proper.
What “Necessary and Proper” Means in a Shooting
The most detailed modern treatment of a state prosecution of a federal agent for a shooting comes out of Ruby Ridge. In 1992, FBI sniper Lon Horiuchi fired the shot that killed Vicki Weaver. Years later, Idaho charged him with involuntary manslaughter. Horiuchi moved the case to federal court and asked the judge to dismiss it on Supremacy Clause immunity, and the district judge did, without an evidentiary hearing.
In 2001 the full Ninth Circuit, sitting en banc, reversed in Idaho v. Horiuchi, 253 F.3d 359. The court described the standard this way: the officer must have done “no more than is necessary and proper in the performance of his duty,” which means showing “an honest and reasonable belief that what he did was necessary in the performance of his duty.” Applying deadly-force law, the court held that it couldn’t say Horiuchi’s shot was objectively reasonable as a matter of law, because the facts underneath it were disputed. Where the facts are disputed, a judge can’t simply dismiss the case on immunity and has to hear the evidence first.
A few months later, the same court vacated the opinion as moot, in Idaho v. Horiuchi, 266 F.3d 979 (9th Cir. 2001). It binds no court today. Its reasoning still shows how the test works when a shooting is contested, and it shows why a fight over immunity usually turns into a fight over facts.
That’s why the evidence matters so much in the Pretti case. Whether an officer’s belief was honest and reasonable is answered with video, scene measurements, witness accounts, the weapons and the officers’ own statements. A prosecutor deciding whether to charge needs that record before deciding, and so does a judge deciding immunity.
Why the Case Would Likely End Up in Federal Court Anyway
If Hennepin County charged a federal agent, the case probably wouldn’t stay in a Minnesota courtroom. A federal statute, 28 U.S.C. section 1442, lets a federal officer remove a state “criminal prosecution” to federal district court when it’s “for or relating to any act under color of such office.” Congress added a provision that, for removal purposes only, treats a law enforcement officer as acting under color of office if the officer was protecting someone present from a crime of violence, helping someone threatened with bodily harm, or stopping the escape of someone the officer reasonably believed had just committed a violent crime.
The Supreme Court has put one condition on removal. In Mesa v. California, 489 U.S. 121 (1989), it held that “federal officer removal under 28 U.S.C. § 1442(a) must be predicated upon averment of a federal defense.” In a case like this one, that defense would be Supremacy Clause immunity.
Removal changes the courtroom more than the case. In Arizona v. Manypenny, 451 U.S. 232 (1981), the Court explained that the federal court “conducts the trial under federal rules of procedure while applying the criminal law of the State.” The county prosecutor still prosecutes, and the charge is still a Minnesota crime. Manypenny also held that the state can appeal an adverse ruling in the removed case if its own law gives it the right to appeal. So a federal judge’s dismissal on immunity wouldn’t automatically be the last word.
Who Holds the Evidence
A state prosecutor charging a state trooper can get the trooper’s agency records with a subpoena. A state prosecutor looking at a federal agent runs into federal rules about federal files. The Justice Department’s regulations, often called Touhy regulations after United States ex rel. Touhy v. Ragen, 340 U.S. 462 (1951), bar its employees from producing department material in response to a demand “without prior approval of the proper Department official.” Touhy held that a subordinate FBI agent could lawfully refuse a subpoena under that kind of rule. In practice, a state’s request goes to the agency, and the agency decides.
That’s how this case has played out. On the night of the shooting, Minnesota went to federal court, and a judge issued a temporary restraining order barring federal agencies from destroying or altering evidence. Judge Eric Tostrud later dissolved it. KSTP reported that he found the government “not likely to destroy or improperly alter evidence” and pointed to the agencies’ own preservation policies. When we spoke, the order was still in place, and I said the judge stepping in “signals that the court sees a real legal question here about whether the balance of power has tilted too far” to the federal side.
Moriarty then sent Touhy letters asking for the guns, reports, GPS data and witness statements. ProPublica reported that on February 13 the FBI said it wouldn’t share its investigative materials in the Pretti case. On March 24, Moriarty, Ellison and the Bureau of Criminal Apprehension sued the Justice Department and the Department of Homeland Security in federal court in Washington, D.C., for the evidence in three shootings, Sahan Journal reported.
In July, MPR News reported that federal authorities had handed over hard drives with statements and body camera footage from the Renee Good shooting and had shared evidence from the Pretti and Julio Sosa-Celis shootings too. The Pretti family’s lawyer, Steve Schleicher, said the U.S. attorney “refused to confirm any cooperation agreement between state and federal agencies,” and added, “No family should be required to beg federal authorities to do their job.” FOX 9 reported in August that the family still didn’t know what evidence the state had received.
Everything in the immunity analysis depends on that record. A prosecutor can’t judge whether an officer’s belief was honest and reasonable without the video, the statements and the physical evidence, and a defense lawyer can’t test a charge without them either.
Why Other States Are Watching
The ProPublica report quoted the Brennan Center’s Alicia Bannon saying the Supreme Court hasn’t heard a Supremacy Clause immunity case in more than 100 years. That leaves lower courts to apply Neagle to modern use-of-force facts, and it means whatever happens in Minnesota will be read closely elsewhere. When I spoke with Valley News Live, I said, “Other states are going to be watching this closely,” because the case “has so much potential impact,” and that the outcome could “shape how future deaths” involving federal agents “are investigated across the country, not just Minnesota.”
That still holds whether or not charges are ever filed. Who controls the scene, who gets the evidence, and how a court weighs immunity when the facts are disputed are questions the next state will face too.
Common Questions
Can a state prosecutor charge a federal agent with a crime?
Yes. Federal officers can be charged under state criminal law. They can raise Supremacy Clause immunity as a defense, which applies when the officer was doing a job federal law authorized and did no more than was necessary and proper to do it.
What is Supremacy Clause immunity?
It’s a defense that comes from In re Neagle (1890). A federal officer can’t be convicted under state law for an act federal law authorized if the officer did no more than was necessary and proper. Courts have described it as requiring an honest and reasonable belief that the conduct was necessary to the officer’s duty.
Would a state case against a federal agent stay in state court?
Usually not. Under 28 U.S.C. section 1442, a federal officer can remove a state prosecution to federal court by raising a federal defense such as immunity. The federal court then applies the state’s criminal law, and the state prosecutor still tries the case.
Has anyone been charged in the Alex Pretti shooting?
As of November 17, 2026, no charges have been reported. The Hennepin County Attorney’s Office has said its review is ongoing, and the Justice Department has said its investigation is ongoing.
Why couldn’t Minnesota just subpoena the federal evidence?
Justice Department regulations require approval from the proper department official before an employee produces department files in response to a demand. Minnesota asked through that process, sued in federal court for the evidence, and later received some material, according to news reports.
If Federal Officers Are Part of Your Case
Most cases never get near a fight like this one, but the evidence questions are the same in any case where a federal officer was on the scene. Save any video you or a witness recorded and keep the original file. Ask your lawyer whether a preservation letter should go to every agency involved, state and federal. Ask whether federal records will have to come through an agency’s own approval process, and how long that’s likely to take. And ask whether any part of the case could end up in federal court.
The firm’s pages on homicide charges in Florida, self-defense and Stand Your Ground and police records and body camera video in Tampa Bay cover how this evidence works in a Florida case, and Know Your Rights During an ICE Encounter covers what to do when immigration officers stop you.
Further Reading
- ABC News, Alex Pretti’s parents seek answers from federal government 9 months after son’s killing, October 27, 2026
- MPR News, Feds turn over evidence in ICE shootings, but Pretti family says U.S. Attorney won’t confirm agreement, July 13, 2026
- FOX 9, ICE shootings: Where do Minnesota’s criminal investigations stand?, August 20, 2026
- ProPublica, Minnesota’s Fight to Hold Agents Who Shot Alex Pretti, Renee Good Accountable
- Sahan Journal, Minnesota officials sue feds for evidence in Good, Pretti killings, March 24, 2026
- Minnesota Attorney General’s Office, order preventing DHS from destroying evidence related to the fatal shooting of Alex Pretti, January 25, 2026
- In re Neagle, 135 U.S. 1 (1890)
- Idaho v. Horiuchi, 253 F.3d 359 (9th Cir. 2001) (en banc), vacated as moot, 266 F.3d 979 (9th Cir. 2001)
- Mesa v. California, 489 U.S. 121 (1989)
- Arizona v. Manypenny, 451 U.S. 232 (1981)
- 28 C.F.R. section 16.22, Justice Department production of material in proceedings where the United States is not a party
This post is general information about a pending investigation as of November 17, 2026, drawn from public reporting and court opinions, and it is not legal advice. No one has been charged, and nothing here describes or judges any officer’s conduct or predicts any decision. Every case is different, and reading this does not create an attorney-client relationship. Authorities discussed: U.S. Const. art. VI, cl. 2; 28 U.S.C. section 1442; 28 C.F.R. sections 16.21 and 16.22; In re Neagle, 135 U.S. 1 (1890); United States ex rel. Touhy v. Ragen, 340 U.S. 462 (1951); Arizona v. Manypenny, 451 U.S. 232 (1981); Mesa v. California, 489 U.S. 121 (1989); and Idaho v. Horiuchi, 253 F.3d 359 (9th Cir. 2001) (en banc), vacated as moot, 266 F.3d 979 (9th Cir. 2001).

