Drugs on Cash: What an Ion Scan Can and Can’t Show

In June 2000 a Florida state trooper stopped a driver for speeding and seized the $15,000 he was carrying. Two days later a Coast Guard ion scan found what the trial court called “high levels of cocaine” on the bills. The judge still found no probable cause to hold the money, and the Fourth District Court of Appeal agreed in Department of Highway Safety & Motor Vehicles v. Jones, 780 So. 2d 949 (Fla. 4th DCA 2001).

The scan wasn’t wrong. There was cocaine on that money. There’s cocaine on most money, and the studies below show how it gets there. An agency wants a judge to read a scan alarm as a link between your cash and a drug deal, when what it mostly shows is that the bills have been in circulation in the United States.

If police in Florida took your cash, the clock matters more than the chemistry at first. The notice of seizure starts a 15-day window to demand a hearing where the agency has to show probable cause, the minimum showing it needs to keep holding the money (section 932.703(3)(a)). The Florida asset forfeiture page walks through that hearing and the rest of the process.

Follow this site in Google:

What the Printout Says, and What It Doesn’t

The instrument is an ion mobility spectrometer, sold under the name IONSCAN. Someone swabs or vacuums the bills, the sample is heated, and the machine times how fast charged molecules drift down a tube. Each drug has a programmed window of drift times. When a peak lands in a window and clears a set threshold, the screen says ALARM and names the drug.

The Pennsylvania National Guard’s counterdrug program has scanned seized cash for police since 1996, and its written procedure explains the printout. There’s a check run with a known test substance before and after the sample, and an “air blank” swabbed from the officer’s hands and the paper under the money. Then there’s the sample, with a “Max Amp” figure the procedure defines as peak height “in digital units.”

Digital units aren’t grams. A survey that started in the FBI Laboratory used the IONSCAN only to screen, and sent samples to a lab for the actual amounts, because the instrument’s response “is not sufficiently linear” at low levels “to allow quantitation by this instrument alone.” A big Max Amp means a strong signal. It doesn’t tell anyone how much cocaine was on your money.

The Bank-Cash Number Every Alarm Gets Compared To

Programs that use these scans in court compare the seized money with a baseline from ordinary bank cash, often called a “casual contact” average. In the Pennsylvania program’s 2013 figures, county averages ran from about 194 digital units to about 591, with a statewide figure of 420.09. The same seized sample could sit above one county’s number and below another’s.

That program’s procedure tells operators they aren’t trained scientists and to say they don’t know when a question goes past their training. In a sworn 2014 affidavit in a Pennsylvania public records appeal, its operator stated that the agency didn’t have “any validation studies” for its use of the instrument. A scan offered against your money should come with its baseline: whose bank cash, from where, in what year, how many samples, and run on the same instrument with the same settings.

How Money That Never Touched a Drug Picks It Up

During a 1993 federal investigation, bank cash screened in West Columbia, Texas, included $100 bills from a teller’s drawer reading around 80 nanograms of cocaine per bill. The bills were brand new, in serial-number order, fresh from the Federal Reserve. The bank had run them through its counting machine, and a swab from inside the counter gave what the researchers called “a massive cocaine peak.”

They tested it directly with counters at the Federal Reserve Bank in San Francisco. New bills straight from the Bureau of Engraving and Printing tested below the lab’s cutoff. After one pass through counters that handled circulating cash, they averaged 2.67 nanograms per bill. In their words, “a single exposure to a contaminated currency counter will contaminate the bills to the ambient level.” That’s Jourdan and colleagues in the Journal of Forensic Sciences (2013).

A DEA chemist in Chicago saw the same thing in 1985, finding cocaine on the belts of the Federal Reserve’s high-speed sorting machine, and wrote that this kind of trace testing on money “is at best limited” as forensic evidence.

Two Studies, Two Scales

A nanogram is a billionth of a gram and a microgram is a thousand nanograms. Keep that in mind, because the two big currency studies measured on different scales.

Oyler, Darwin and Cone at the National Institute on Drug Abuse soaked whole $1 bills from 14 cities, Miami among them, and measured cocaine with GC-MS, a lab instrument that separates a sample and identifies each chemical in it. Cocaine topped 0.1 microgram on 79% of the bills and 1 microgram on 54%. One bill from Portsmouth, Ohio carried 1,327 micrograms, more than a milligram. They concluded that cocaine “in amounts up to 1 mg per bill does not signify that the currency was involved in a drug transaction.”

Jourdan’s group vacuumed one side of 4,174 bills, in 418 groups of ten, from 66 cities in 43 states and Washington, D.C., between 1993 and 2009. About 97% of the groups (405 of 418) had measurable cocaine, averaging 2.34 nanograms per bill. Florida cash varied by neighborhood: Miami bank cash averaged 2.83 nanograms per bill and Fort Lauderdale 0.102.

The two studies land a thousandfold apart on the same drug in the same country, because one soaked whole bills and the other vacuumed one face. A number from a cash test means something only beside a baseline gathered the same way.

Jourdan’s group also found that 68 samples from FBI criminal cases carried more cocaine than bank cash. About half the bank samples were under 0.5 nanograms per bill, while about half the case samples reached up to 20. They argue the amount, “as opposed to its mere presence,” can point to trafficking. Fair enough, but that argument needs a measured amount from a lab and a local baseline collected the same way. A Max Amp from a screening instrument is neither one.

Where a Scan Fits in a Florida Case

Florida lets an agency seize cash with no arrest at all, because money is one of the exceptions to the arrest rule in section 932.703(1)(a). Keeping it takes more. At trial the agency has to prove “beyond a reasonable doubt” that the property was used in violation of the forfeiture law, and a jury decides unless the owner waives one (section 932.704(3) and (8)).

A scan alarm doesn’t get an agency close to that by itself. Jones said that “a positive alert by a drug dog to narcotics on currency, standing alone, does not constitute evidence that the money was used in a drug transaction,” then weighed the ion scan with everything else and still found only suspicion.

Scans show up in criminal cases too. In State v. Exantus, 59 So. 3d 359 (Fla. 2d DCA 2011), Lee County deputies got a search warrant before ion-scanning the inside of a car where they’d found about $83,220, and the Second District, which covers Tampa Bay, upheld the warrant. The scan reported trace MDMA and cocaine. The court decided whether the warrant was valid. It didn’t decide what the scan proved.

Crime labs don’t treat ion mobility as enough on its own either. The seized-drug standard from the Scientific Working Group for the Analysis of Seized Drugs, the SWGDRUG Recommendations, ranks it below mass spectrometry and requires more than one technique before a lab names a drug. A National Institute of Standards and Technology study of the same instrument put it plainly: “As with any presumptive test, the uncertainties lie in the potential for false positives.”

When cash was taken in a drug investigation and a scan is in the file, I ask for:

  • every printout from the session, including both check runs and each air blank, with times;
  • the alarm thresholds set that day, and the instrument’s cleaning and maintenance log;
  • the baseline data, with where, when and how it was collected;
  • who handled the money between the seizure and the scan, and where it was kept;
  • whether the bills went through any counting machine first; and
  • any lab measurement of the actual amount, with the method used.

Questions People Ask About Drugs on Money

Is there cocaine on most U.S. money?

Most circulating bills carry a trace. A survey of 4,174 bills from 1993 to 2009 found measurable cocaine on about 97% of the ten-bill samples, averaging 2.34 nanograms per bill, and a 1996 study found it on 79% of $1 bills above 0.1 microgram. Money-counting machines spread it to bills that never touched a drug.

Can Florida police keep my cash because an ion scan or drug dog found drugs on it?

They can seize cash without an arrest, but keeping it is a separate fight. At a forfeiture trial the agency has to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the money was used in violation of the law, and a Florida appeals court has held that a dog alert to currency, standing alone, isn’t evidence the money was used in a drug transaction.

Read the Studies and Cases

  1. Jourdan, Veitenheimer, Murray and Wagner, “The Quantitation of Cocaine on U.S. Currency: Survey and Significance of the Levels of Contamination,” Journal of Forensic Sciences 58(3) (2013).
  2. Oyler, Darwin and Cone, “Cocaine Contamination of United States Paper Currency,” Journal of Analytical Toxicology 20(4) (1996).
  3. Verkouteren and Staymates, “Reliability of ion mobility spectrometry for qualitative analysis of complex, multicomponent illicit drug samples,” Forensic Science International (2010).
  4. Department of Highway Safety & Motor Vehicles v. Jones, 780 So. 2d 949 (Fla. 4th DCA 2001).
  5. State v. Exantus, 59 So. 3d 359 (Fla. 2d DCA 2011).
  6. Section 932.703 and section 932.704, Florida Statutes.

This post is general information about the law, not legal advice, and it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome. The law discussed is sections 932.703 and 932.704, Florida Statutes; Department of Highway Safety & Motor Vehicles v. Jones, 780 So. 2d 949 (Fla. 4th DCA 2001); and State v. Exantus, 59 So. 3d 359 (Fla. 2d DCA 2011). The studies discussed are Jourdan et al., J. Forensic Sci. 58(3) (2013), and Oyler, Darwin and Cone, J. Anal. Toxicol. 20(4) (1996).

Available 24/7 for Immediate Defense

Your first strategy session is free. One call can start protecting your future today.
Get in Touch

You’re better Safir than sorry!

Arrested for DUI? Time matters. Complete the form to schedule a free strategy session with attorney Rory Safir. Your information is confidential, and we will follow up promptly.

200+
Client Testimonials
1 of 6
Forensic Lawyer-Scientists in Florida
4.9★
Google Rating
24/7
Availability

Let’s Go Over Your Case


Email Newsletter