In Brief
Rex Heuermann pleaded guilty on April 8, 2026, to seven Gilgo Beach murders, admitted an eighth, and was sentenced on June 17 to life without parole. The DNA that tied him to the case started with a pizza crust he threw away in Manhattan and a mitochondrial match to a hair on a victim, then moved to whole genome sequencing of rootless hairs, which a Suffolk County judge admitted after a Frye hearing in September 2025. Because of the plea, no jury ever heard that science and no witness was cross-examined on it at trial.
On This Page
- Where the Case Ended
- The Pizza Box on Fifth Avenue
- What a Mitochondrial Match Can and Can’t Say
- Why Rootless Hairs Were a Dead End, Until They Weren’t
- The Frye Ruling That Let It In
- Admissible Isn’t the Same as Tested
- Common Questions
- If Hair DNA or a Discarded Sample Is in Your Case
- Further Reading
On April 8, 2026, the day Rex Heuermann pleaded guilty in the Gilgo Beach killings, I joined CBS News New York to talk about why. My read was that a plea like that is “more likely a calculation from the defense team that probably the evidence wasn’t survivable. There wasn’t a path to acquittal.” When the anchor asked about the DNA, I pointed to how investigators “ultimately matched his DNA from a discarded pizza box to hair that was found on some of the victim’s remains,” and that “they had a couple different labs that confirmed it.”
That DNA deserves a closer look than a news segment allows. The hairs in this case were tiny, old and rootless, the kind of sample that used to be a dead end. Getting a nuclear DNA result from them took a technique borrowed from ancient DNA research, and a Suffolk County judge spent nine days of hearings deciding whether a jury could hear it. Then the plea meant no jury ever did.
Where the Case Ended
Heuermann, a Manhattan architect from Massapequa, was arrested on July 13, 2023. On April 8, 2026, WSHU reported, he changed his pleas to guilty in the murders of seven women and admitted killing an eighth, Karen Vergata, whose death was never charged. The seven were Melissa Barthelemy, Megan Waterman, Amber Costello, Maureen Brainard-Barnes, Jessica Taylor, Sandra Costilla and Valerie Mack. As part of the plea he agreed to cooperate with the FBI’s behavioral analysis unit.
On June 17, 2026, Justice Timothy Mazzei sentenced him to life in prison without parole, ABC7 New York reported. The same judge had written the DNA ruling nine months earlier.
The Pizza Box on Fifth Avenue
Investigators needed Heuermann’s DNA without tipping him off. According to the bail application, as CBS News reported it, a surveillance team watched him throw a pizza box into a garbage can on Fifth Avenue in Manhattan on or about January 26, 2023, and recovered it. The Suffolk County Crime Laboratory swabbed the leftover crust. In April a detective hand-delivered a male hair found on Megan Waterman’s remains to the same lab, and in June the lab reported that the mitochondrial DNA profiles from the crust and the hair were the same.
Collecting DNA someone throws away is a common move in cold cases. The Supreme Court held in California v. Greenwood, 486 U.S. 35 (1988), that the Fourth Amendment doesn’t prohibit the warrantless search and seizure of garbage left for collection outside the curtilage of a home. A pizza box in a public trash can on a Manhattan sidewalk is further from the home than that. In a discarded-sample case, the harder questions are usually about what the lab did with it.
What a Mitochondrial Match Can and Can’t Say
The first link was mitochondrial DNA, and that matters. Mitochondrial DNA is passed down from mother to child almost unchanged, so it isn’t unique to one person. Everyone in a maternal line, a mother, her children and her sister’s children, carries the same profile. The bail filing said the result excluded 99.96 percent of the North American population. Put the other way, about 4 in every 10,000 people wouldn’t be excluded, along with every maternal relative.
That’s a strong lead and a weak identification. It narrows the field without naming one person, and on its own it can’t tell a man from his brother. That’s why the next step in this case mattered so much. Prosecutors needed nuclear DNA, the kind inherited from both parents, from hairs that had no root.
Why Rootless Hairs Were a Dead End, Until They Weren’t
Standard forensic DNA testing counts short tandem repeats, stretches of DNA where a few bases repeat over and over. That method needs reasonably long, intact pieces of DNA. A hair shaft without its root holds very little nuclear DNA, and what’s there is broken into tiny fragments, especially after years outdoors. The hairs recovered from the remains weren’t suitable for that kind of testing when they were found.
Prosecutors sent them to Astrea Forensics, a California lab owned by Dr. Richard Green, a professor of biomolecular engineering at the University of California, Santa Cruz, whose research has pulled DNA out of Neanderthal, cave bear and mammoth bones. Astrea used whole genome sequencing. Instead of looking for a handful of long repeat regions, the lab reads millions of short fragments from across the whole genome and looks at single nucleotide polymorphisms, or SNPs, single spots where people’s DNA differs. A software program Green created, called IBDGem, then compares that data with a known reference sample and reports a likelihood ratio.
According to Justice Mazzei’s decision, the program asks two questions: how likely is the hair data if it came from a person with the genotype in the suspect’s cheek swab, and how likely is it if it came from “an unknown, unrelated individual.” Green testified that his peer-reviewed paper on IBDGem, published in early 2023, rested on a study of rootless hairs and saliva from eight people, and that the program gave strong support to the known right answer in every test.
The Frye Ruling That Let It In
New York decides whether new science reaches a jury under the Frye test, named for a 1923 federal case. The question, as the Court of Appeals framed it in People v. Wesley, 83 N.Y.2d 417 (1994), and Justice Mazzei quoted it, is “whether the accepted techniques, when properly performed, generate results accepted as reliable within the scientific community generally.” The side offering the new science carries the burden of proving that general acceptance.
The hearing ran nine days between March 28 and July 17, 2025. The prosecution called Green, Dr. Kelley Harris, a population geneticist at the University of Washington, and Dr. Nicole Novroski of the Center for Human Identification at the University of North Texas. The defense called Dr. Krane, a molecular biologist who has written about cognitive bias and statistical weight in DNA interpretation, and a software witness. Their criticisms included the size of the reference panel IBDGem uses, the 1000 Genomes Project, which holds genomes from 2,504 people.
On September 3, 2025, in People v. Heuermann, 2025 NY Slip Op 25203, Justice Mazzei found that Astrea’s method was “generally accepted as reliable within the scientific community,” relying on the testimony, the peer-reviewed literature and the technique’s use in other jurisdictions, including Idaho and California. He found that neither defense witness provided “empirical proof to refute the validated empirical evidence,” and ordered the nuclear DNA results from rootless hairs connected to six victims admissible at trial. The Associated Press reported that prosecutors and others called it the first time this kind of DNA analysis had been admitted in a New York court.
Admissible Isn’t the Same as Tested
A Frye ruling answers one question: is the method generally accepted, so a jury may hear it? It doesn’t decide whether the lab ran it correctly on these hairs, whether the numbers mean what the witness says, or how much weight a jury should give them. Those questions get answered at trial, through cross-examination, and this case never got there.
Here are a few of the questions a trial would have put to the witnesses. The likelihood ratio compares the suspect with an unrelated person, so what does the number look like when the alternative is a brother, a son or a cousin? How much of each hair was used up in testing, and was anything left for the defense to retest? How was the lab validated for casework, as opposed to research, and who checked the bench work? And how did hairs travel onto the remains in the first place? CBS News reported that investigators found female hairs on Waterman and Costello that his wife couldn’t be excluded from, though she was out of state during each murder and was never charged. Investigators believed those hairs moved from his clothing. That’s a reminder that DNA speaks to whose it is, and says nothing on its own about when or how it got somewhere.
Because Heuermann pleaded guilty, none of that was argued in front of a jury. The Heuermann decision is a published trial-court ruling, the first of its kind in New York, with no verdict built on it and, as far as public reporting shows, no appellate review. Prosecutors elsewhere can cite it, and the next lawyer facing whole genome sequencing results won’t have a trial record from this case to work from.
Common Questions
How did police get Rex Heuermann’s DNA?
A surveillance team recovered a pizza box he threw into a garbage can on Fifth Avenue in Manhattan around January 26, 2023, and the Suffolk County Crime Laboratory tested DNA from the crust, according to the bail application as reported by CBS News.
What is whole genome sequencing in a criminal case?
It reads millions of short DNA fragments from across the genome and compares single-letter differences, called SNPs, instead of the longer repeat regions standard tests use. That lets a lab get a nuclear DNA profile from degraded samples like rootless hairs.
Did the judge allow the whole genome sequencing evidence?
Yes. On September 3, 2025, Justice Timothy Mazzei ruled after a Frye hearing that Astrea Forensics’ whole genome sequencing results from rootless hairs were admissible at trial. Prosecutors described it as the first such ruling in New York.
Was the DNA evidence ever tested by a jury?
No. Heuermann pleaded guilty on April 8, 2026, before trial, so no jury heard the DNA evidence and the witnesses were never cross-examined on it in front of one.
What sentence did Rex Heuermann receive?
Justice Mazzei sentenced him on June 17, 2026, to life in prison without parole.
If Hair DNA or a Discarded Sample Is in Your Case
Few cases involve a decade-old serial investigation, but hair evidence and discarded samples show up in ordinary ones too. If a lab report says your DNA was found, ask whether it’s mitochondrial or nuclear DNA, because those mean very different things. Ask what the alternative explanation in any likelihood ratio was, and whether a relative was ever considered. Ask how much of the sample is left and whether your side can test it. And ask how the sample was collected, packaged and moved before the lab saw it.
I wrote about how investigators build a name from a relative’s DNA in genetic genealogy and Florida’s cold case program, and about how labs go wrong in a case where a DNA analyst went to prison for deleting results. The firm’s pages on DNA and serology defense and homicide defense cover how this evidence works in a Florida case.
Further Reading
- People v. Heuermann, 2025 NY Slip Op 25203 (Sup. Ct. Suffolk County Sept. 3, 2025)
- Associated Press via The Daily Record, Judge allows advanced DNA evidence in Gilgo Beach serial killing trial, September 3, 2025
- CBS News, How a Chevy, a strand of hair and a pizza box led police to the Gilgo Beach suspect, July 15, 2023
- WSHU via WRVO, Accused Long Island serial killer pleads guilty, April 8, 2026
- ABC7 New York, Gilgo Beach serial killer sentenced to life in prison without parole, June 2026
- California v. Greenwood, 486 U.S. 35 (1988)
This post is general information about a concluded New York case as of November 17, 2026, drawn from the court’s published decision and public reporting, and it is not legal advice. Nothing here predicts the outcome of any other case. Every case is different, and reading this does not create an attorney-client relationship. Authorities discussed: People v. Heuermann, 2025 NY Slip Op 25203, 88 Misc 3d 513 (Sup. Ct. Suffolk County 2025); People v. Wesley, 83 N.Y.2d 417 (1994); Frye v. United States, 293 F. 1013 (D.C. Cir. 1923); and California v. Greenwood, 486 U.S. 35 (1988).

