Hunter S. Thompson’s Death Review: How Investigators Re-Examine a 20-Year-Old Case

In Brief

On January 23, 2026, the Colorado Bureau of Investigation affirmed that Hunter S. Thompson’s 2005 death was a suicide. Most of the original physical evidence and photographs had been disposed of under non-criminal retention schedules, so the review rested on the records, the autopsy reports, interviews and a 2025 trajectory reconstruction built from a bullet defect still intact in the home. A review asks whether the original work holds up; reopening a case takes new evidence that contradicts it, and the CBI found none.

My comments for Fox News Digital on the CBI’s review of Hunter S. Thompson’s death, January 2026. Watch on YouTube or see the Fox News Digital video.

When the Colorado Bureau of Investigation finished its review of Hunter S. Thompson’s death this year, I talked with Fox News Digital about what that kind of review involves. The first thing I said is the one that tends to get lost: “It doesn’t mean that original investigation was flawed.” Thompson died on February 20, 2005, at Owl Farm, his home in Woody Creek, Colorado. The Pitkin County Sheriff’s Office concluded it was a suicide. On January 23, 2026, more than 20 years later, the CBI announced that its independent review affirmed that conclusion.

The question I find more interesting than the result is how an agency goes back to a death investigation that’s two decades old. Some of the evidence is still there to check, some of it’s gone for good, and the work of a review is figuring out which is which.

Follow this site in Google:

How the Review Started

According to the CBI’s January 23, 2026, release, the review began with a written request from the Pitkin County Sheriff’s Office on July 31, 2025. That request followed a call from Thompson’s widow, Anita Thompson, to Sheriff Michael Buglione with what the CBI called “new concerns and potential information regarding the investigation into the death.”

When the CBI announced the review on September 30, 2025, it said the sheriff’s position was that there was no new evidence suggesting foul play, and that his office was committed to answering any lingering questions. Neither agency has said publicly what Anita Thompson raised. The Associated Press reported that a CBI spokesperson declined to comment on it.

A Review Isn’t a Reopening

Those are two different things, and the difference explains most of what happened here. A case review asks whether the original work holds up. Reopening a case means treating the death as an open investigation again, and that takes more than questions. As I told Fox News Digital, “they would need some kind of new evidence that would materially contradict or undermine what they originally found. And that didn’t happen here.” The CBI said the same thing in its own words: the review “did not uncover any new physical evidence, facts, or circumstances to support a conclusion different from the 2005 investigation.”

Who does the review matters too. The sheriff’s office that ran the first investigation asked a state agency to do this one. “While we have always believed the original investigation was conducted properly, we recognized the importance of an independent review for the Thompson family,” Sheriff Buglione said in the CBI’s release. An outside agency has no stake in defending the first conclusion, and that’s what gives its answer weight when the answer comes back the same.

What Can Still Be Checked After 20 Years

Paper lasts longer than physical evidence. The CBI said its agents reviewed the sheriff’s office records and the autopsy reports from forensic pathologist Dr. Dean Havlik. Autopsy findings are written down, measured and usually photographed, so a second set of eyes can test whether the wound described fits the explanation given, even decades later.

People are the next source, and they don’t last forever either. The CBI interviewed Anita Thompson, Thompson’s son Juan, his former daughter-in-law Jennifer, the original lead investigator, Ron Ryan, the Pitkin County coroner, Dr. Steven Ayers, and Joe DiSalvo, a former Pitkin County sheriff and undersheriff. “They would have looked at what would have been the original reports, any of the autopsy materials,” I said in the Fox interview. “I know they interviewed some of the witnesses that were still around, the original investigators as well as re-examining the scene using the evidence that was available.” Memory fades and changes over 20 years, so interviews this late are most useful when they can be checked against what the same people wrote or said at the time.

The scene itself was the third source. The house was still there, and as it turned out, so was part of the physical record of the shot.

What Can’t Be Re-Tested

The CBI said a scene examination “was necessary as most original physical evidence and photographs had been disposed of by the PCSO in accordance with non-criminal case retention schedules.” Once the death was ruled a suicide, the case was no longer a criminal one, so its evidence fell under the sheriff’s schedule for non-criminal cases. The release doesn’t list which items were disposed of.

That limit is real. Anything that was destroyed can’t be retested with newer methods, examined by a fresh analyst or compared against anything found later. Some tests can’t be redone even when the evidence survives. Gunshot residue on a person’s hands, for example, has to be collected soon after a shooting, so it’s either part of the original investigation or it isn’t part of any investigation. A 20-year review works with what the first investigators chose to collect and what the retention schedule let survive.

Some of what was lost came back from outside the agency. The AP reported, citing the CBI, that original crime scene photos recovered by Anita Thompson showed the body’s position matched the path of the bullet. When material reaches investigators from outside their own files, part of the job is documenting where it came from and checking it against what the original reports describe, the same way any chain of custody gets rebuilt.

The Bullet Defect That Was Still There

The piece of evidence that carried the most weight wasn’t in an evidence locker at all. The CBI said its 2025 trajectory analysis and scene reconstruction were “based on the intact bullet defect.” According to the AP, a CBI spokesperson said investigators tracked the bullet’s path with the help of a fragment still lodged in an appliance in the home.

A fixed defect is valuable because it doesn’t move. Investigators can measure the angle of the hole, run a line back from it, and compare that line with the wound path in the autopsy report and the body position in the scene photographs. If those three agree, the reconstruction supports the original account. If they don’t, that’s the kind of new fact that could justify reopening a case. Here, the CBI said the reconstruction “was consistent with the original PCSO investigation, the autopsy report, and the observations of original investigators.” The AP reported the CBI also found the body “was not moved or ‘staged’ after death.”

That’s where I expected the weight of the review to be. “I would imagine a big part of their confirming their findings had to do with the bullet trajectory reconstruction and using kind of modern technology to validate the original findings,” I told Fox News Digital.

Why a Review That Changes Nothing Still Matters

A review that confirms the first answer can look like wasted effort, but a finding that a separate agency has checked with new tools, against the physical evidence that survived, is stronger than one nobody ever checked. In the video of my comments, I put it this way: “not that we should just blindly trust them,” but investigators have now reached the same result twice.

It also answers the speculation in the only way that holds up. “As far as what’s out there on the internet, I would say that just a lot of this speculation and internet theories are not evidence,” I said. “This is a criminal investigation. It’s going to be grounded in evidence, not in, you know, internet theories.” The CBI’s own summary, as the AP reported it, was that “all speculative theories could not be substantiated.” And Anita Thompson, who asked for the review, said in the CBI’s announcement that it “allows all of us who loved Hunter to move forward with a clean conscience.”

Common Questions

What did the CBI conclude about Hunter S. Thompson’s death?

On January 23, 2026, the Colorado Bureau of Investigation announced that its independent review affirmed the original 2005 finding that Thompson died by suicide. It found no new physical evidence, facts or circumstances supporting a different conclusion.

Why was Hunter S. Thompson’s death reviewed 20 years later?

Thompson’s widow, Anita Thompson, contacted the Pitkin County sheriff with new concerns and potential information. The sheriff’s office asked the CBI in writing on July 31, 2025, to conduct an independent review. Neither agency has said publicly what the concerns were.

Is a case review the same as reopening a case?

No. A review checks whether the original investigation holds up. Reopening a death investigation generally takes new evidence that materially contradicts or undermines the original finding, and the CBI said its review found none.

How can investigators reconstruct a shooting 20 years later?

In this review, the CBI used a bullet defect that was still intact in the home. Investigators compared the bullet’s path with the autopsy report, the scene photographs and the original investigators’ observations, and the CBI said they were consistent.

Why was the original evidence destroyed?

The CBI said most of the original physical evidence and photographs were disposed of by the sheriff’s office under its retention schedules for non-criminal cases. Because the death was ruled a suicide, the case fell under those non-criminal schedules.

If an Old Investigation Is Part of Your Case

Very few families or defendants deal with a review this public, but the same questions come up whenever an old investigation matters to a case. Ask what the agency kept and what it disposed of, and get its retention schedule in writing. Ask for the full autopsy report, the photographs and the investigators’ notes, not just the final ruling. Find out whether any physical evidence that could carry a new test, like a bullet defect, a firearm or a stored sample, still exists. And if a second opinion is coming, ask who’s giving it and whether they had any part in the first one.

The firm’s pages on medical and autopsy evidence, challenging firearm evidence and forensic science defense cover how this evidence works in a Florida case. I also wrote about how decades-old cases get solved with genetic genealogy and the cold case program.

Further Reading

  1. Colorado Bureau of Investigation, CBI Completes Review of Hunter S. Thompson Death Investigation; Confirms Original Conclusion of Suicide, January 23, 2026
  2. Colorado Bureau of Investigation, CBI Conducting Case Review into Death of Hunter S. Thompson, September 30, 2025
  3. Associated Press, Review confirms journalist Hunter S. Thompson’s 2005 death was a suicide, January 23, 2026
  4. Fox News Digital, Hunter S. Thompson suicide ruling stands firm after 20-year review by Colorado investigators, February 1, 2026
  5. Fox News Digital video, Colorado investigators confirm Hunter S. Thompson death was suicide following independent review

This post is general information drawn from the Colorado Bureau of Investigation’s public releases and the news reports cited above, current as of November 17, 2026. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. It offers no opinion beyond the public record about Hunter S. Thompson’s death or anyone involved in it.

Available 24/7 for Immediate Defense

Your first strategy session is free. One call can start protecting your future today.
Get in Touch

You’re better Safir than sorry!

Arrested for DUI? Time matters. Complete the form to schedule a free strategy session with attorney Rory Safir. Your information is confidential, and we will follow up promptly.

200+
Client Testimonials
1 of 6
Forensic Lawyer-Scientists in Florida
4.9★
Google Rating
24/7
Availability

Let’s Go Over Your Case


Email Newsletter