Can a U.S. Court Try Maduro After a Military Capture? Ker-Frisbie, Immunity and the Noriega Case

In Brief

Yes, a U.S. court can generally try someone brought here by force. Under the Ker-Frisbie doctrine, how a defendant arrived doesn’t take away the court’s power to try him, and the Eleventh Circuit applied that rule to Manuel Noriega in Miami. Nicolás Maduro’s motion to dismiss on head-of-state immunity is set for oral argument before Judge Analisa Torres on December 17, 2026, and trial is set for June 14, 2027. His lawyers have preserved, but not yet raised, a challenge to the capture itself.

On LiveNOW from FOX, January 2026, on the federal charges, the Noriega precedent and head-of-state immunity. Watch on YouTube.

In January I went on LiveNOW from FOX and on FOX 35 Orlando to talk about Nicolás Maduro, a week after U.S. forces took him from Caracas to New York. The question I kept coming back to was whether a court can try him at all. I said then that it was going to be “a long drawn out and slow process,” and that the judge would have to rule on immunity and jurisdiction before anything else. Ten months later, that’s exactly where the case sits.

Maduro and his wife, Cilia Flores, are presumed innocent, and nothing here predicts how their case ends. What follows is the law the judge has to apply, the arguments each side has filed and where things stand as of November 17, 2026.

Follow this site in Google:

Where the Case Stands

U.S. forces captured Maduro and Flores in a nighttime military operation in Caracas early on January 3, 2026, and flew them to New York, the Associated Press reported. They face a narco-terrorism conspiracy case in the Southern District of New York that dates back to an indictment first filed in 2011.

On October 6, 2026, a grand jury returned a fifth superseding indictment. According to the defense’s own motion, it adds new factual allegations, adds Flores to counts that had named only Maduro, and charges both of them with a new count of conspiracy to commit torture under 18 U.S.C. § 2340A. Both entered not guilty pleas at an October 15 arraignment before Judge Alvin Hellerstein.

Judge Hellerstein died on October 28, at 92, NBC News reported. The case was reassigned that day to Judge Analisa Torres. On October 29 she ordered that every deadline and date Judge Hellerstein had set, including the trial date, stays in place.

Early reporting had pointed to a November 17 hearing on Maduro’s motion to dismiss. That date didn’t hold. The court docket shows that at the October 15 arraignment, oral argument was moved to December 17, 2026, at 11 a.m. Maduro refiled his immunity motion against the new indictment on November 9, the government’s response is due November 30, and the defense reply is due December 14. Trial is set for June 14, 2027. As of today, no ruling on immunity has been entered.

How He Got Here Usually Doesn’t Matter: Ker-Frisbie

Many folks assume that if the capture was illegal, the case has to be thrown out. American law has run the other way for 140 years.

In Ker v. Illinois, 119 U.S. 436 (1886), a man was seized in Peru by an agent who never used the extradition papers he was carrying and was brought back to Illinois for trial. The Supreme Court held that he got the process the Constitution requires because he was regularly indicted and tried. In Frisbie v. Collins, 342 U.S. 519 (1952), Michigan officers allegedly seized a man in Chicago, handcuffed and blackjacked him, and drove him to Michigan. The Court said it “has never departed from the rule announced in Ker v. Illinois” that a court’s power to try someone isn’t impaired by a “forcible abduction,” and that due process is satisfied by fair notice of the charges and a fair trial.

The Court went further in United States v. Alvarez-Machain, 504 U.S. 655 (1992). DEA agents arranged to have a Mexican doctor abducted from Mexico, over Mexico’s objection, to face charges in a federal agent’s murder. The Court held that the U.S.-Mexico extradition treaty didn’t forbid that, so Ker applied and the abduction was no defense to the court’s jurisdiction. It acknowledged the abduction may have violated general principles of international law, and said whether to return him was a question for the Executive Branch, not the courts.

Together these are called the Ker-Frisbie doctrine. The question in a courtroom is usually whether the trial will be fair, not how the defendant arrived.

The Narrow Exception the Defense Is Saving for Later

There’s one crack in that rule, and it comes from the same federal circuit that covers Manhattan. In United States v. Toscanino, 500 F.2d 267 (2d Cir. 1974), Toscanino alleged that American agents kidnapped him in Uruguay, tortured him and brought him to the United States. The Second Circuit held that due process requires a court to give up jurisdiction when it was obtained through the government’s “deliberate, unnecessary and unreasonable invasion of the accused’s constitutional rights,” and sent the case back for a hearing on his claims. A year later, in United States ex rel. Lujan v. Gengler, 510 F.2d 62 (2d Cir. 1975), the same court narrowed it: without that kind of shocking conduct by U.S. agents, Ker-Frisbie controls. The court added that an abduction claim under international law depends on whether the country the person was taken from protested, and Lujan didn’t allege that Argentina or Bolivia ever objected. Venezuela’s government has objected to Maduro’s capture from the start.

Maduro hasn’t made that argument yet. In a footnote to his November 9 brief, his lawyers say discovery about what they call the “violent abduction” of Maduro and Flores through a military operation is relevant to a jurisdictional challenge on that independent basis, citing Toscanino, and that he “is not raising now but fully preserves” it. The court’s schedule allows a second round of pretrial motions, due February 12, 2027.

When I was on LiveNOW in January, I said the defense would look at suppression issues “about how he got into the country” and at whether the court even has jurisdiction. That’s the fight being set up now.

Head-of-State Immunity: The Motion Before the Court

The argument the defense is pressing first is immunity. Under the common law, a sitting head of state can’t be prosecuted in another country’s courts, and foreign officials can be immune for acts they took in their official role. Maduro’s brief claims both kinds. It argues he was Venezuela’s president when he was taken, that Venezuela’s acting government has asserted his immunity and has not waived it, and that a court shouldn’t defer to the Executive Branch when its position runs against the common law.

The government’s answer rests on recognition. Its October 2 opposition says the United States hasn’t recognized Maduro as Venezuela’s president since January 2019, that recognizing foreign governments is the President’s power, and that head-of-state immunity depends on status at the time of the court proceedings. It argues that by the time Maduro was charged, arrested and prosecuted, he was a de facto ruler who held no office in the eyes of the United States.

The defense has a real distinction to work with. In January I said Maduro has “a little bit of a better argument” on head-of-state immunity than Noriega did, because Maduro was at least arguably a sitting head of state once, and the United States recognized him as president before 2019. The government calls that distinction meaningless because, in its view, only present status counts. That’s the question Judge Torres will hear argued on December 17.

The Florida Precedent: Noriega in Miami

The closest case on the books was tried in Florida. Manuel Noriega surrendered to U.S. military officials on January 3, 1990, after the U.S. invasion of Panama, and was brought to Miami to face federal drug charges in the Southern District of Florida. A jury convicted him on eight counts.

On appeal, in United States v. Noriega, 117 F.3d 1206 (11th Cir. 1997), the Eleventh Circuit rejected the same kinds of arguments the Maduro defense is making now. On immunity, it said that “by pursuing Noriega’s capture and this prosecution, the Executive Branch has manifested its clear sentiment that Noriega should be denied head-of-state immunity.” It added that Noriega never served as Panama’s constitutional leader, that Panama hadn’t sought immunity for him, and that the charged acts related to his “private pursuit of personal enrichment.” On the invasion, it held that his due process claim fell within Ker-Frisbie, and that the Alvarez-Machain decision foreclosed his extradition treaty argument. It didn’t reach the Toscanino exception, because Noriega never alleged that the government mistreated him personally.

The government’s brief in the Maduro case calls the Noriega trial court the only district court to consider a head-of-state immunity claim in a criminal case. As I said on LiveNOW, “there is certainly precedent here and in the Noriega case, they rejected any kind of head of state immunity.” Maduro’s case is different in two ways the defense is pushing: a past period of U.S. recognition, and a government at home that has demanded his immunity. Whether those differences change the answer is what the motion will decide.

On FOX 35 Orlando, January 2026, on whether Florida could bring its own charges. Watch on YouTube.

Could Florida Charge Him Too?

The second segment, on FOX 35 Orlando, was about Governor Ron DeSantis saying the state was looking at state charges. I told them, “it’s not a matter of if Florida could bring charges. It’s a matter of whether they could prove it and whether it’s worth even pursuing.”

The double jeopardy piece is settled law. In Gamble v. United States, 587 U.S. 678 (2019), the Supreme Court kept the dual-sovereignty doctrine, under which a state and the federal government can each prosecute the same conduct because each is enforcing its own laws. The harder part is proof: a Florida prosecutor would have to show conduct that reached Florida specifically, not just the United States in general. As I said on air, the federal case would come first, and custody is no longer the hurdle it usually is, because he’s already here.

Common Questions

Can a U.S. court try someone who was captured abroad by force?

Generally, yes. Under the Ker-Frisbie doctrine, the Supreme Court has held that a forcible abduction doesn’t take away a court’s power to try the person, as long as the trial itself is fair. The Second Circuit recognized a narrow exception in United States v. Toscanino for outrageous government conduct, and later decisions have read it narrowly.

Does Maduro have head-of-state immunity?

That’s the motion pending before Judge Analisa Torres. The defense says he was Venezuela’s president when he was captured and that Venezuela hasn’t waived his immunity. The government says the United States hasn’t recognized him as president since January 2019 and that courts defer to that decision. Oral argument is set for December 17, 2026.

Who is the judge in the Maduro case now?

Judge Analisa Torres of the Southern District of New York. The case was reassigned to her on October 28, 2026, after Judge Alvin Hellerstein died, and she ordered that his schedule, including the trial date, stays in place.

When is Maduro’s trial?

The court docket sets jury selection and trial for June 14, 2027, with a final pretrial conference on June 8, 2027.

Why does the Noriega case matter?

Noriega was captured after a U.S. military operation, tried in Miami and convicted, and the Eleventh Circuit rejected his head-of-state immunity and illegal capture arguments in 1997. The government relies on it in the Maduro case, and the defense argues Maduro’s past recognition as president sets him apart.

If How You Were Arrested Is Part of Your Case

Very few people are arrested by a military operation, but the rule from these cases reaches ordinary arrests too. An illegal arrest usually doesn’t end a prosecution by itself. What it can do is keep out the evidence that came from it. If the way you or someone you love was stopped or arrested seems wrong, ask the lawyer what the officers had before they acted, what was found because of the arrest, and whether a motion to suppress fits the facts. If a state and the federal government are both looking at the same conduct, ask how one case affects the other.

The firm’s pages on double jeopardy in Florida, drug trafficking and mandatory minimums and drug crimes defense cover how these issues come up in a Florida case.

Further Reading

  1. Associated Press via PBS News, on Maduro’s arrival in New York to face charges after the U.S. operation, January 4, 2026
  2. NBC News, Alvin K. Hellerstein, federal judge who presided over Trump, Maduro and 9/11 cases, dies at 92, October 28, 2026
  3. Court docket, United States v. Maduro Moros, No. 1:11-cr-00205 (S.D.N.Y.)
  4. Ker v. Illinois, 119 U.S. 436 (1886)
  5. Frisbie v. Collins, 342 U.S. 519 (1952)
  6. United States v. Alvarez-Machain, 504 U.S. 655 (1992)
  7. United States v. Noriega, 117 F.3d 1206 (11th Cir. 1997)
  8. Gamble v. United States, 587 U.S. 678 (2019)

This post is general information about a pending case as of November 17, 2026, drawn from the public court docket and news reporting, and it is not legal advice. Nicolás Maduro and Cilia Flores are presumed innocent, and nothing here predicts the outcome of their case or any other. Every case is different, and reading this does not create an attorney-client relationship. Authorities discussed: Ker v. Illinois, 119 U.S. 436 (1886); Frisbie v. Collins, 342 U.S. 519 (1952); United States v. Alvarez-Machain, 504 U.S. 655 (1992); United States v. Toscanino, 500 F.2d 267 (2d Cir. 1974); United States ex rel. Lujan v. Gengler, 510 F.2d 62 (2d Cir. 1975); United States v. Noriega, 117 F.3d 1206 (11th Cir. 1997); Gamble v. United States, 587 U.S. 678 (2019); and 18 U.S.C. § 2340A.

Available 24/7 for Immediate Defense

Your first strategy session is free. One call can start protecting your future today.
Get in Touch

You’re better Safir than sorry!

Arrested for DUI? Time matters. Complete the form to schedule a free strategy session with attorney Rory Safir. Your information is confidential, and we will follow up promptly.

200+
Client Testimonials
1 of 6
Forensic Lawyer-Scientists in Florida
4.9★
Google Rating
24/7
Availability

Let’s Go Over Your Case


Email Newsletter