Does Hiring a Lawyer Make Your Pain Last Longer?

At eight emergency rooms in Florida, Michigan, Massachusetts and New York, researchers asked 948 people about their pain within a day of a car crash, then asked again six weeks later. By then, the 148 people who had hired a lawyer and were suing reported more pain than everyone else. They had also reported more pain on the first day, in the ER, before any of them had a lawyer.

When an insurance company argues your pain is lasting because you hired a lawyer, the day-one numbers are the first thing to set against it. The study is McLean and colleagues, published in 2014 in the journal Pain, and it tracked the same people from the ER bed to week six.

Follow this site in Google:

Day One, Before Any Lawyer

Research assistants interviewed every patient in the emergency department, hours after the crash. Weeks later, at the six-week follow-up, 859 of them answered again and were asked whether they had hired a lawyer and were suing for damages or workers’ compensation. The people who ended up suing had been hurting more in the ER:

  • neck pain rated 4.5 out of 10 on average, against 3.5 for the people who didn’t sue;
  • overall pain of 6.4 out of 10, against 5.3; and
  • pain in more parts of the body.

Pain in the ER predicted pain at six weeks in both groups. That suggests part of the gap runs the other way: people hurt worse on day one may have been more likely to need a lawyer by week six.

Week Six

Six weeks after the crash Not suing (711 people) Suing (148 people)
Pain from the crash somewhere in the body 69% 95%
Moderate or severe neck pain 28% 64%
Pain in 7 or more body regions 13% 41%

The authors reported every one of those gaps as statistically significant, meaning chance is an unlikely explanation. A defense doctor can quote those week-six numbers accurately. The numbers don’t show which came first, the pain or the lawsuit, and the authors wrote that their design couldn’t settle that directly.

Because people who weren’t suing outnumbered those who were almost five to one, most of the lasting pain in the study belonged to people who never sued: 68% of all the moderate or severe neck pain and 60% of the widespread pain. Only 5% of everyone with moderate or severe neck pain at six weeks had reported similar symptoms before the crash.

What the Defense Will Quote

Some findings do lean toward the lawsuit side. Among people who were suing, lacking health insurance or full-time work predicted lasting pain, and people with no pain at all in the ER were more likely to sue if they were uninsured or earned under $40,000 a year. The authors wrote that litigation “may (consciously or unconsciously) influence pain persistence or worsening pain.”

Their overall reading was that the influence runs in both directions. In their words, the data “provide evidence for bidirectional influences between pain outcomes and litigation after MVC,” a motor vehicle collision. The same paper shows the pain was there before any lawsuit, tracked how badly people were hurt on day one and turned up at high rates in people who weren’t suing.

Florida was one of the four study states, all of them no-fault states, where your own insurance pays the first medical bills and where the authors note that litigation over lasting crash pain is more restricted. Everyone enrolled was a white, non-Hispanic adult from 18 to 65 who went home from the ER, because the study also collected genetic data. The outcome stopped at six weeks, and the authors wrote that the effect of litigation “at later time points is not known.”

If a Defense Medical Report Mentions Secondary Gain

Secondary gain is the suggestion that you are staying hurt because a claim might pay you. The ER chart is written hours after the crash, before any claim exists. Among people who weren’t suing, three things written down in the ER predicted moderate or severe neck pain six weeks later: being female, severe neck pain that day and severe overall pain that day. So tell the ER or urgent care about every place that hurts, and keep telling each provider the same thing. In Florida that first visit also matters for money: personal injury protection (PIP), the part of your own car insurance that pays first, covers medical benefits only if you get initial care within 14 days of the crash, as my page on how PIP works explains.

When a report suggests your pain is about the claim, set it against your own ER chart: the pain score written that day, where in the body it was recorded and what treatment followed. My page on the insurance company playbook after a Florida crash covers the arguments that usually travel with this one, the whiplash and neck injury page covers how a neck injury is proven, and my post on whether a low-speed crash can hurt you takes on the claim that the crash was too small.

Questions About Pain and Lawsuits

Do people who hire a lawyer after a car accident report more pain?

In a 2014 study of 859 crash patients at eight emergency rooms, including in Florida, those who were suing reported more neck pain and widespread pain six weeks later. They had also reported worse pain in the ER before any lawsuit, and people who weren’t suing carried most of the lasting pain in the study.

What does secondary gain mean in a defense medical report?

It’s the suggestion that a person benefits from staying hurt, such as through a settlement, and that the benefit keeps symptoms going. The 2014 crash study found that litigation and pain may influence each other, and that lasting pain after a crash was common in people who weren’t suing.

Further Reading

  1. McLean and colleagues, incidence and predictors of neck and widespread pain after motor vehicle collision among US litigants and nonlitigants, Pain (2014)
  2. Section 627.736, Florida Statutes (personal injury protection benefits)

This post is general information about Florida law and published research as of this writing, including section 627.736, Florida Statutes. It is not medical advice or legal advice about any specific case, and it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Available 24/7 for Immediate Defense

Your first strategy session is free. One call can start protecting your future today.
Get in Touch

You’re better Safir than sorry!

Arrested for DUI? Time matters. Complete the form to schedule a free strategy session with attorney Rory Safir. Your information is confidential, and we will follow up promptly.

200+
Client Testimonials
1 of 6
Forensic Lawyer-Scientists in Florida
4.9★
Google Rating
24/7
Availability

Let’s Go Over Your Case


Email Newsletter