Truck Driver Sleep Apnea: The Medical Records That Matter After a Truck Crash

In Brief

In a 2016 study at one large carrier, truck drivers diagnosed with sleep apnea who never used their treatment had about five times the rate of serious preventable crashes of 2,016 comparison drivers with similar experience and time on the job. Drivers who used their treatment had the same crash rate as the comparison group. Federal rules require a trucking company to keep each driver’s medical certificate on file, so after a truck crash the driver’s sleep and medical records are evidence to ask for early.

If you were hurt in a St. Petersburg or Pinellas County crash, start with my St. Petersburg car accident lawyer page. For other kinds of injuries, see my St. Petersburg personal injury lawyer page.

When a tractor-trailer drifts across a lane or rear-ends traffic that had stopped, the first questions are usually about hours: how long the driver had been on duty, and whether the logbook matches the truck’s electronic records. A second question gets asked far less often. Did the driver have a sleep disorder, and was it being treated?

A large study of truck drivers answered part of that question with crash data, and it’s why a driver’s medical file belongs in the first records request in a truck case.

Follow this site in Google:

What Sleep Apnea Does to a Driver

Obstructive sleep apnea is a condition in which the airway closes over and over during sleep, so a person wakes up many times a night without knowing it. The 2016 study discussed below describes it as “the most common medical cause of excessive daytime sleepiness or fatigue,” and links it to problems with attention, vigilance and executive function. The usual treatment is a machine worn at night that keeps the airway open with air pressure, often called CPAP. Many of these machines record how many hours they were used each night.

The Study Behind the Fivefold Number

A research team from the University of Minnesota, Virginia Tech, Harvard and other institutions studied the first large employer-mandated sleep apnea program in American trucking (Burks and colleagues, Sleep, 2016). The carrier screened its drivers, sent those at risk for a sleep study, and required diagnosed drivers to use a treatment machine as a condition of keeping the job. The machines reported each driver’s actual use.

The researchers compared 1,613 drivers diagnosed with sleep apnea against 2,016 drivers unlikely to have it, matched on experience and time on the job, and sorted the diagnosed drivers by how well they used treatment. Full adherence meant meeting the standard of at least four hours of use a night on at least 70% of nights.

The 360 drivers who never used their machine had a rate of serious preventable crashes that the authors call “fivefold greater” than the matched drivers: 0.070 against 0.014 crashes per 100,000 miles (incidence rate ratio 4.97). Drivers with full adherence had the same rate as the comparison group, 0.014 per 100,000 miles. The authors counted only crashes reportable to the Department of Transportation and judged preventable, the kind that involve the driver’s own conduct.

The drivers who refused treatment were fired or quit fast, staying one-third as long as the others. The authors wrote that the rules then in place allowed such a driver to keep driving “at another firm by keeping their diagnosis private.” A driver with an untreated diagnosis may have moved on to a different company, which is why a driver’s full employment and medical history can matter more than the current carrier’s file.

What the Study Can and Can’t Show

The study came from one carrier, and the drivers chose whether to use their treatment, so the groups weren’t assigned at random. The authors call that their primary limitation and explain that a randomized trial withholding a proven treatment from drivers wouldn’t be ethical. The study also shows risk across a group. It can’t say that sleep apnea caused any one crash. That link has to come from the facts of your crash: the driver’s history, the hours worked, the time of day, and what the truck’s data shows the driver did, or didn’t do, before impact.

The Federal Medical Rules for Truck Drivers

Federal regulations set the physical standards for interstate commercial drivers. A driver is physically qualified only if the driver “has no established medical history or clinical diagnosis of a respiratory dysfunction likely to interfere with his/her ability to control and drive a commercial motor vehicle safely” (49 C.F.R. 391.41(b)(5)). The rule doesn’t name sleep apnea, so whether a driver with sleep apnea is certified depends on the medical examiner’s judgment of that driver, including whether the condition is being treated.

The trucking company has to keep a driver qualification file for each driver it employs, and that file has to include “the medical examiner’s certificate” or a legible copy, or, for many CDL drivers, the state driving record showing medical certification (49 C.F.R. 391.51). The medical examination itself produces a longer record of the driver’s health history and the examiner’s findings. Those documents can show whether sleep apnea was screened for, diagnosed, treated or certified around.

The Records to Ask For After a Truck Crash

In a truck case where fatigue is a real possibility, I ask the trucking company to preserve, and later produce, these records:

  • the driver qualification file, including every medical examiner’s certificate and the full examination forms;
  • any sleep apnea screening, referral, sleep study, diagnosis and treatment records the carrier holds;
  • the treatment machine’s usage data, if the carrier monitored it;
  • the carrier’s written policy on sleep apnea screening and treatment;
  • the driver’s hours of service and electronic logging data for the days before the crash; and
  • the names of the driver’s prior employers, which the application in the qualification file should list.

These records sit with the company, and routine retention schedules can erase some of them. My page on truck crash evidence and the black box covers the preservation letter, a written demand that the company keep this evidence, and the page on FMCSA safety regulations covers the other federal rules that apply.

First Steps After a Truck Crash

Get medical care, get the crash report number, and photograph the truck, its trailer, and any company name or DOT number on the doors. Don’t give a recorded statement to the trucking company or its insurer before you’ve talked to a lawyer. A truck case often has more than one responsible party, and my page on who is liable in a truck crash explains how that works. The truck accidents section covers each stage of a Florida truck case.

Common Questions

Does sleep apnea increase truck crash risk?

In a 2016 study of truck drivers at one large carrier, drivers diagnosed with sleep apnea who never used their prescribed treatment had about five times the rate of serious preventable crashes of matched drivers. Drivers who used treatment fully had the same rate as the comparison group.

Can a truck driver with sleep apnea legally drive?

Federal rules require an interstate truck driver to have no respiratory condition likely to interfere with safe driving, and a medical examiner decides whether a driver meets that standard. The rule doesn’t name sleep apnea, so a treated driver may be certified while an untreated driver may not.

Can I get a truck driver’s medical records after a crash?

The trucking company must keep a driver qualification file that includes the driver’s medical examiner’s certificate. In a lawsuit, those records and related medical information can be requested during discovery, the stage where each side must hand over evidence, and a preservation letter should go out early so nothing is lost to routine deletion.

What does a CPAP machine record?

Many treatment machines record nightly hours of use. In the 2016 study, the carrier monitored that data and used it to sort drivers by whether they met the standard of four hours a night on at least 70% of nights.

Further Reading

  1. Burks and colleagues, nonadherence with employer-mandated sleep apnea treatment and increased risk of serious truck crashes, Sleep (2016)
  2. 49 C.F.R. 391.41, physical qualifications for drivers
  3. 49 C.F.R. 391.51, driver qualification files

This post is general information about federal trucking regulations and published research as of this writing, including 49 C.F.R. 391.41 and 391.51. It is not medical advice or legal advice about any specific case, and it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Available 24/7 for Immediate Defense

Your first strategy session is free. One call can start protecting your future today.
Get in Touch

You’re better Safir than sorry!

Arrested for DUI? Time matters. Complete the form to schedule a free strategy session with attorney Rory Safir. Your information is confidential, and we will follow up promptly.

200+
Client Testimonials
1 of 6
Forensic Lawyer-Scientists in Florida
4.9★
Google Rating
24/7
Availability

Let’s Go Over Your Case


Email Newsletter