In Brief
When an insurer calls your MRI findings “degenerative,” the research behind that word is studies like a 2015 review of 3,110 people with no back pain: disc bulges showed up in 30% of 20-year-olds and 84% of 80-year-olds. The same paper says those findings “must be interpreted in the context of the patient’s clinical condition,” and that it does not conclude they are always age-related. In Florida, a crash that makes an existing condition worse is still an injury you can recover for, and if a jury can’t separate the old from the new, the jury instruction tells it to award damages for the entire condition.
Read alongside this: how preexisting conditions work in a Florida injury claim.
On This Page
If you were hurt in a St. Petersburg or Pinellas County crash, start with my St. Petersburg car accident lawyer page. For other kinds of injuries, see my St. Petersburg personal injury lawyer page.
You never had neck or back trouble. Then a car hit you, an MRI showed a disc bulge, and a few weeks later the adjuster wrote that your findings are “degenerative” and were there before the crash. The offer that follows is small, or there isn’t one.
The research behind that letter is real, and its own authors wrote that these findings “must be interpreted in the context of the patient’s clinical condition.” The study says a good deal more than an adjuster’s letter quotes.
The Word on Your MRI Report
Radiologists describe what they see. “Degenerative” on a report means wear-type changes are visible: a disc that has lost some water and height, a bulge, bone spurs or thickened joints. The word says nothing about when those changes started, and it says nothing about whether they hurt.
Insurers read it to mean the condition was already there and the crash didn’t cause it. The step from what a scan shows to what caused your pain is the step the research doesn’t support.
The Study Insurers Point To
In 2015, a team led by radiologists at the Mayo Clinic and the University of Washington pooled 33 studies that scanned the lower backs of 3,110 people with no back pain (Brinjikji and colleagues, American Journal of Neuroradiology). The question was how often “degenerative” findings show up in people who feel fine. The answer, by age:
- disc degeneration rose from 37% of 20-year-olds to 96% of 80-year-olds;
- disc bulges rose from 30% at age 20 to 84% at age 80;
- disc protrusions, a more focused push of disc material past its normal edge than a broad bulge, rose from 29% to 43%; and
- annular fissures, small tears in the disc’s outer ring, rose from 19% to 29%.
Those numbers are why an adjuster calls your findings ordinary. Plenty of people walk around with a bulging disc and no pain at all. If you were one of them before the crash, the study describes you.
What the Authors Said About Their Own Numbers
The authors draw a clear line around what their review means. Their conclusion is that these findings “must be interpreted in the context of the patient’s clinical condition.” In other words, a scan alone doesn’t answer the question. What the patient feels, when it started, and what the exam shows have to be read with it.
They go further in the limitations section: “Our study does not imply or conclude that the above-mentioned degenerative findings are always age-related rather than pathologic.” They also note the findings “were not stratified by the degree of severity,” and that people without symptoms may have milder changes than people with them. The review covered lower back scans only, so it says less about the neck.
So the study shows that a bulge on a scan doesn’t prove a crash caused it. By the same logic, it doesn’t prove a crash didn’t make it hurt. A finding that was silent before and painful after is exactly what the authors tell clinicians to sort out from the patient’s history.
How Florida Treats an Aggravated Condition
Florida law doesn’t require you to have had a perfect spine before the crash. The standard instruction Florida judges read to juries on aggravation tells jurors to try to decide what portion of your condition came from the aggravation, and to award damages for that portion if they can. Then it says: “However, if you cannot make that determination, or if it cannot be said that the condition would have existed apart from the injury, then you should award damages for the entire condition” suffered by the injured person.
In a degenerative case, if the defense can’t show how much of your pain would have existed without the crash, the instruction doesn’t leave you with nothing. My page on preexisting conditions explains aggravation, acceleration and activation in more detail.
Before and After Is the Proof
Because the scan can’t settle it, the record of your life before and after the crash does. That means your medical history before the crash, including the absence of any neck or back treatment; what you told the emergency room and your first doctor; when each symptom started; and what you could do before that you can’t do now. People who knew you before the crash can describe the change, and a treating doctor who has your full history can explain why the timing points to the crash.
Prior imaging is valuable when it exists. A scan from before the crash that shows the same bulge and a patient with no complaints is strong support for aggravation. A later scan showing something new is stronger still. My page on herniated disc and spine injuries covers how a spine case is built.
If Your Claim Was Cut as Degenerative
Don’t hide a prior injury or prior treatment. Old records can be requested in a claim, and a hidden history can hurt a claim more than the old injury itself. Gather the names of every doctor, chiropractor and clinic you saw before the crash, even years ago, so the full history can be requested. Keep a simple record of your symptoms and the things you’ve stopped doing. And don’t accept the adjuster’s reading of your MRI as the final word, because the research it rests on says the scan has to be read with you.
The serious injuries section and my whiplash and neck injury page go further into how a spine claim is handled.
Common Questions
What does degenerative mean on an MRI after a car accident?
It means the radiologist saw wear-type changes such as disc dehydration, a bulge or bone spurs. The word doesn’t say when the changes started or whether they cause pain, and a 2015 review of lower back scans found such findings common in people with no back pain at all.
Can I still have a claim if my MRI shows degenerative disc disease?
Yes. Florida’s jury instruction on aggravation allows damages when a crash aggravates an existing condition, and if the jury can’t separate what existed before from what the crash caused, it tells jurors to award damages for the entire condition.
How common are disc bulges in people without pain?
In a 2015 review of 3,110 people with no back pain, disc bulges appeared in 30% of 20-year-olds and 84% of 80-year-olds. The authors say these findings must be read in the context of the patient’s clinical condition.
How do I prove a crash made my back or neck worse?
With the before and after: medical records showing no complaints or treatment before the crash, symptoms documented from the day of the crash, prior imaging if any exists, and a treating doctor who knows your full history.
Further Reading
This post is general information about Florida law and published research as of this writing, including Florida Standard Jury Instruction (Civil) 501.5 (aggravation or activation of a disease or defect). It is not medical advice or legal advice about any specific case, and it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

