The 6 mL Blood Tube Studies: What the Fort Worth Papers Tested and What They Didn’t

The Fort Worth Police Department’s crime lab ran two studies on whether a 6 mL blood tube with 15 mg of preservative works as well as a 10 mL tube with 100 mg. The preservative is sodium fluoride, a powder in the tube added to hold back the microbial activity that could change the alcohol level after the draw. Both tubes are gray-tops, named for their gray caps, from the same manufacturer. A 2019 tube recall renewed the question, and the 2021 paper describes itself as the first direct comparison of these two tubes.

Neither one tested the tubes the way blood actually gets drawn in a DUI case, and the 2023 paper says so in its own text. In Florida there’s a second problem: the state’s blood rule calls for a glass tube, and the 6 mL tube in these studies is plastic.

Follow this site in Google:

The Two Fort Worth Papers

The first is Olds and Naquin, published in the Journal of Forensic Sciences in 2021. The second is a follow-up by Olds in the same journal, volume 68, in 2023. Both authors worked at the Fort Worth Police Department Crime Laboratory, and both papers thank the department “as the sponsor of this work.” The first paper explains why the question came up: a 2019 recall of 10 mL gray-top tubes after some were found with no additive inside, and local press questions about whether the department’s tubes could change blood-alcohol results.

The 2021 study spiked blood at 0.04, 0.08 and 0.15, put it into 90 pairs of 6 mL and 10 mL tubes at three fill levels, and tested them over 30 days. Most pairs showed no statistically significant difference. At 0.08 grams per 100 mL, Florida’s legal limit, one of the statistical tests found the two tube sizes gave different results, and the authors wrote that this “warrants further study.” The 2023 paper went back and tested only 0.08, in refrigerated tubes, with eight of each tube size per condition, out to 90 days.

The Concentrations Nobody Tested

The 6 mL tube is described as 0.25% sodium fluoride and the 10 mL tube as 1%. Those percentages only hold when each tube is filled to its full volume, because the powder is a fixed amount and the percentage depends on how much blood goes in. The 2021 paper filled the 6 mL tubes with 2, 3 or 4 mL of blood, which its own table lists as 0.75%, 0.50% and 0.38% fluoride. The 10 mL tubes got 3, 5 or 7 mL, or 3.33%, 2.00% and 1.43%.

So the comparison everyone cares about, 0.25% against 1%, never appears in the data. Every 6 mL tube in the study had more preservative per mL of blood than a full 6 mL tube would. The 2021 paper still ends by saying samples in tubes “containing less than 0.25% sodium fluoride can be considered statistically equivalent” to 1% tubes under most of the conditions tested. The lowest level in its own table is 0.38%.

Bank Blood, Pipettes and Open Tubes

Neither study involved a person. The blood came from a blood bank and was tested to make sure it had no alcohol in it. The lab then added alcohol from a 20% solution and pipetted the blood into the tubes. The 2023 paper says the pipetting “required removal of the tube closures,” after which the tubes were recapped. It also notes that the blood bank units contain added solutions, including dextrose, and that the units were past their expiration date.

In a real draw, skin is cleaned, a needle goes into a vein, and the blood is pulled straight into a sealed vacuum tube. The 2023 paper lists oxygen exposure during preparation and the use of blood bank product as limitations, notes that blood handled in an unsterile setting can pick up microbes that can “increase (generate) or decrease (consume) ethanol,” and closes by saying further studies are needed “under real-world conditions.”

Which Tube Read Higher

Don’t expect these papers to prove the small tube inflates a result. They don’t, and the direction wasn’t even consistent between them. In the 2021 study, where refrigerated tube pairs differed, the 6 mL tube gave the higher number in nearly every case. In the 2023 study, where pairs differed, the 6 mL tube read lower, at 7 and 30 days, and the author found the differences fell inside the lab’s own precision range, which the paper called not “analytically significant,” meaning the gaps were small enough to sit inside the lab’s normal day-to-day variation. By 90 days the two sizes matched again.

What the two papers do show is narrower. The tubes aren’t identical, the differences show up at 0.08 where a few thousandths matter, and a sample changes in the tube over time. A third paper by the same author, in 2023, reports retesting unopened 6 mL tubes from real cases after months or years in storage. I haven’t read the full text of that third paper, so I leave its numbers out, but it’s worth asking any lab analyst whether it’s part of what they rely on.

The Florida Question: Glass

Florida’s blood collection rule, 11D-8.012(2) of the Florida Administrative Code, says blood “must be collected in a glass evacuation tube that contains a preservative such as sodium fluoride and an anticoagulant such as potassium oxalate or EDTA (ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid).” The table in the 2021 paper lists the 6 mL tube it studied, reference number 367925, as plastic. The 10 mL tube, 367001, is glass.

The rule allows compliance to be shown by the stopper or label on the tube, the manufacturer’s documentation, or other evidence. It also says that any blood result, “if proved to be reliable,” can still be accepted. In State v. Miles, 775 So. 2d 950 (Fla. 2000), the Florida Supreme Court repeated its earlier rule that “[n]one of the statutory presumptions can apply in the absence of compliance with the administrative rules.” Without them, the State can still offer the result, but it has to show the old way that the test was reliable, that a qualified person ran it on proper equipment, and, through an expert, what the number means. A plastic tube doesn’t throw out a blood result by itself, but it makes the State do more work, and a study done in a plastic tube can’t be used to say the tube satisfied a rule that names glass.

My tube inversions page covers what the preservative and anticoagulant are supposed to do, and the fermentation page covers what can happen to alcohol in a sample that isn’t properly preserved.

Questions I Ask About the Tube

When a DUI case rests on a blood draw, I treat the tube itself as evidence. I ask for the tube’s reference number and lot, the manufacturer’s certificate for that lot, whether the tube was glass or plastic, how full it was, and how long it sat before testing. I also ask which studies the lab relies on to say its tubes preserve a sample, and whether any of them used real blood draws or real casework samples rather than spiked bank blood. If the answer is the two Fort Worth papers, the lab is relying on work its own author says still needs real-world testing.

The rest of a blood review, from the draw to the lab, is on my DUI blood test defense page, and the DUI defense section covers every stage of a Florida DUI case.

Further Reading

The sources behind this post, so you can read what I read.

  1. Olds and Naquin, “Statistical comparisons of blood alcohol samples from 6-mL and 10-mL grey-top tubes,” Journal of Forensic Sciences 66(2):687-693 (2021)
  2. Olds, “Statistical comparisons of 0.08 g/100 ml fortified blood alcohol samples from 6-ml and 10-ml gray-top tubes,” Journal of Forensic Sciences 68(1):301-307 (2023)
  3. Rule 11D-8.012, Florida Administrative Code, blood samples, labeling and collection
  4. State v. Miles, 775 So. 2d 950 (Fla. 2000)

This post is general information about the law, not legal advice, and it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome. The law discussed is Rule 11D-8.012, Florida Administrative Code, and State v. Miles, 775 So. 2d 950 (Fla. 2000). The studies discussed are Olds and Naquin, J. Forensic Sci. 66(2):687-693 (2021), and Olds, J. Forensic Sci. 68(1):301-307 (2023).

Available 24/7 for Immediate Defense

Your first strategy session is free. One call can start protecting your future today.
Get in Touch

You’re better Safir than sorry!

Arrested for DUI? Time matters. Complete the form to schedule a free strategy session with attorney Rory Safir. Your information is confidential, and we will follow up promptly.

200+
Client Testimonials
1 of 6
Forensic Lawyer-Scientists in Florida
4.9★
Google Rating
24/7
Availability

Let’s Go Over Your Case


Email Newsletter