Terrion Arnold surrendered to authorities and is being held in a Florida jail with no bond at all, and the State has signaled it will ask a judge to keep him locked up until trial because, it argues, he is a danger to the community. He is presumed innocent and has not been convicted of anything. Still, the situation raises the question I hear most from families: how can a person be held with no bond before a trial even happens?
The answer is one of the most important early fights in any serious Florida case.
This is general legal commentary on a publicly reported, unresolved case. Mr. Arnold is presumed innocent, this is not legal advice, and The Safir Lawyer does not represent anyone in this matter.
Most charges carry a bond. A few do not
For most arrests in Florida, a person gets a bond, often from a statewide schedule, and sees a judge at first appearance within 24 hours. But the Florida Constitution carves out an exception for the most serious cases. When the charge is punishable by life or death, as armed robbery and kidnapping can be, the State is allowed to ask that the person be held with no bond while the case is pending.
The Arthur hearing
When the State wants to hold someone with no bond on a life felony, Florida uses what lawyers call an Arthur hearing, named for the case that set the rule. The burden sits on the State first: it has to show that the proof of guilt is evident or the presumption great, a higher bar than probable cause. If the State cannot meet it, the person is entitled to a reasonable bond. If it can, the judge then decides whether any set of conditions could reasonably protect the community and guarantee the person comes back to court.
What the judge weighs
Florida law, in section 903.046, gives the judge a list to consider: the nature of the charge, the weight of the evidence, the person’s ties to the community, any prior record, the risk of flight, and the danger to others. Those factors cut in different directions for different people. Someone who lives out of state, for example, may face a harder argument on flight risk and community ties than a lifelong local resident.
What a defense lawyer does at that hearing
This is not a moment to sit quietly. A defense lawyer forces the State to prove its proof is evident rather than just assert it, attacks the strength of the evidence, and presents the other side of the ledger: voluntary surrender, a clean record of court appearances, deep community ties, a willingness to wear a monitor or surrender a passport. The difference between having a lawyer ready at first appearance and not having one can be the difference between going home and waiting months in a cell.
What this means in Florida
Being held with no bond feels like the system has already decided. It has not. It is a contested hearing with a real burden on the State, and the earlier a lawyer gets involved, ideally before first appearance, the more a judge hears about why release makes sense.
Charged with a DUI in the Tampa Bay area?
If a loved one is being held with no bond, the clock is already running. Getting a lawyer in before first appearance changes what the judge hears.
About the author
Rory Safir is one of a handful of ACS-CHAL Forensic Lawyer-Scientists in Florida, an NHTSA qualified field sobriety instructor, and a former Assistant Public Defender in Tampa. He trained on the same gas chromatography instruments the State labs use, which is why he reads breath and blood evidence the way an analyst does.
Keep reading
Common Questions
Can you be held in jail with no bond in Florida?
Yes. For charges punishable by life or death, the State can ask a judge to hold a person with no bond while the case is pending, but only after meeting its burden at a special hearing.
What is an Arthur hearing?
It is the Florida hearing where the State must show that the proof of guilt is evident or the presumption great before a person can be held with no bond on a life or capital charge.
What does a judge consider when setting bond in Florida?
Section 903.046 lists factors including the nature of the offense, the weight of the evidence, community ties, prior record, risk of flight, and danger to others.
Does turning yourself in help with bond?
It can. Voluntary surrender and a clean history of showing up to court are factors a judge can weigh in favor of release.